Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles, which are to be subsidised through the German government’s new economic stimulus program with up to 4,500 euros per new car, will not reduce transport emissions, environmental organisation Greenpeace argues in a report.
The majority of hybrid models are heavier and overpowered SUVs and luxury sedans, which limits their ability to reduce emissions, according to the analysis.
The average engine output of currently available plug-in hybrids in Germany was 335 hp, while that of all newly registered cars in 2019 was only 158 hp.
In addition, tests by German automobile association ADAC show that the fuel consumption of hybrid cars in everyday use is many times higher than indicated in dealer information, particularly when the battery is flat, as apparently often occurs.
The table above indicates several well known plug in hybrid models, with the first column being the advertised consumption, the second column being the tests conducted by ADAC, and the third column the tests done with a flat battery. The final column shows the percentage difference.
“If the federal government now promotes the sale of plug-in hybrids, it will only help the car companies’ short-term bottom line, but it will damage the climate,” said Greenpeace transport expert Benjamin Stephan.
“The German auto industry has to adapt quickly to the post-combustion engine era. Deceptive packages like plug-in hybrids delay this change.” The Greenpeaceanalysis evaluated data from the 88 plug-in hybrid models currently available in Germany. Of those, 40 are SUVs, while 21 are upper and upper-middle class models.
Germany’s coalition government agreed this week on an economic stimulus package that, among other measures, aims to boost sales of electric cars and plug-in hybrids with an “innovation bonus”. The premium doubles existing government grants.
Staff reporter and Clean Energy Wire, reproduced with permission.
Giles Parkinson is founder and editor of The Driven, and also edits and founded the Renew Economy and One Step Off The Grid web sites. He has been a journalist for nearly 40 years, is a former business and deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review, and owns a Tesla Model 3.
